Let’s talk about Donald Trump’s belief that he could end a 46-year blood feud with a Truth Social post demanding “PEACEFUL and RESPECTFUL” behavior. The man is too dumb to understand that some conflicts run deeper than hurt feelings and bad dealmaking.
Trump obviously doesn’t know jackshit about the history of these two countries. So, let’s do a quick recap: Before 1979, Israel and Iran were best friends. Israel owed Iran about $1 billion from business deals under the Shah. They had joint missile projects, shared intelligence, collaborated on oil pipelines. Iran was Israel’s closest regional ally.
Then Ayatollah Khomeini showed up and made destroying Israel his religious imperative. Within days, Iran handed the Israeli Embassy to the PLO and declared Israel the “Little Satan.” This wasn’t a policy shift that could be fixed with a treaty or a mediator.
Of course, even while Iran was publicly calling for Israel’s destruction, both countries were secretly selling weapons to each other during the Iran-Iraq War. Israel moved up to $2 billion annually in arms to Iran because they viewed Saddam as the bigger threat. They were simultaneously planning each other’s destruction while doing business in the shadows. (They probably learned that from us.) It should be more than obvious, to anyone with a brain, that this complex relationship can’t be resolved because Trump tells them to make peace.
Not to mention that Iran’s real accomplishment in their defense plan was building the “Axis of Resistance” – proxy forces designed to encircle Israel while maintaining plausible deniability. Hezbollah gets $700 million annually and has become the world’s most heavily armed non-state actor. Hamas gets around $100 million. Add Iraqi militias and Yemeni Houthis, and you have a multi-front threat that operates independently of Tehran’s control.
Even if Iranian leadership genuinely wanted peace tomorrow, they’ve created a monster they can’t fully control. These groups have independent interests in continued conflict and don’t take orders like employees. You can’t just call up the Ayatollah and ask him to turn off Hamas like flipping a switch.
https://rachelandthecity.threadless.com/
Then there’s the shadow war that makes spy novels look quaint. Israel has been systematically assassinating Iranian nuclear scientists for over a decade using everything from motorcycle bombs to AI-controlled weapons. The 2020 killing of Mohsen Fakhrizadeh involved a satellite-controlled machine gun that could identify and eliminate its target with surgical precision. Iran responds with cyber attacks, maritime strikes, and assassination attempts worldwide.
This shadow war operates according to its own logic, independent of whatever diplomatic theater plays out in public. Intelligence services on both sides have institutional interests in continued operations and agent networks that require constant maintenance. You can’t simply pause these programs because a president announced a ceasefire on social media.
The nuclear dimension makes this existential. Israel views Iranian nuclear capabilities as threatening its survival – not unreasonable given Iran’s repeated calls for its destruction. Iran sees nuclear technology as essential for deterrence and regional status. These aren’t negotiating positions – they’re core survival requirements.
The 2015 Iran nuclear deal required 687 days of intensive negotiations among six world powers and produced a 159-page agreement. It was a successful diplomatic achievement that Trump basically tore up and threw in the garbage when he withdrew the US from it in 2018.
I guess Trump thought he could resolve 46 years of ideological conflict, sophisticated proxy networks, ongoing covert warfare, and existential nuclear concerns with a few phone calls and a social media announcement. That’s like calling your feuding children in China and telling them to “Straighten up! Or else!”
Trump treats international relations like business negotiations where both sides want a deal and just need the right incentives. But Israel and Iran aren’t fighting because of miscommunication – they’re locked in an existential struggle where accommodation would require one side to accept permanent strategic disadvantage.
Some problems can’t be solved by better salesmanship or confident negotiating. Some conflicts are structural features of the international system rather than bugs that can be patched with presidential intervention.
Trump just discovered what every serious Middle East analyst already knew – some conflicts are bigger than any single presidency, no matter how much you believe in the power of personal dealmaking. His “forever lasting” peace fantasy revealed a profound misunderstanding of what actually drives this 46-year confrontation.
So here we are, with Trump’s diplomatic masterstroke lasting roughly as long as a TikTok video. The man who once claimed he could solve any problem is now 0-for-1 on ending generational blood feuds via social media announcement. But hey, at least he learned a valuable lesson about the difference between closing a real estate deal and stopping people who’ve been trying to kill each other since Jimmy Carter was president. Actually, scratch that – we all know that Trump doesn’t learn lessons.