EDGE wanted $11,040 to let me see its xAI emails

In today’s episode of Being Stubborn starring me – I just was handed a major win over EDGE trying to charge me $11,000 to view their records.

The xAI files

Every essay in this series is pinned to a question on the board at rachelandthecity.com/the-xai-files.


If you’re new here, EDGE stands for the Economic Development Growth Engine. It’s the agency that hands out tax breaks for the city and county. EDGE is on the lease for the land xAI’s company rents in Pidgeon Industrial Park, which I wrote about in October. For six weeks I’ve been trying to see what EDGE and xAI said to each other.

On October 8th, I asked EDGE for records about xAI’s lease, including EDGE’s emails with the xAI companies – xAI does business here through several of them – and with the Greater Memphis Chamber. EDGE did send me the lease. But for the emails, on October 9th, it asked for an estimated upfront payment of $3,000 before it would produce anything. I asked for a breakdown of that $3,000 three times. I never got one.

So. I thought I was SOL. But then – I did some more research – because how did it make sense that the state has laws allowing citizens to request records – but then allowed us to be charged outrageous amounts to see them?

And then I found the workaround. Under Tennessee law, I should be able to go to an agency’s office and look at public records for free. The law says a government entity can’t charge you to view a public record. And EDGE’s own records policy says it in one line, section V.A: “There shall be no charge for inspection of open public records.”

So on October 16th, I asked to inspect the records in person – no copies – and just to be a pain in their ass – I widened what I asked to see: EDGE’s communications with the xAI companies, with the Chamber, and among EDGE’s staff, its board members, and the Port Commission – EDGE’s partner on the lease – about xAI, from January 1st, 2024 to now.

EDGE missed its seven-business-day deadline to answer.

So, I followed up on October 29th. The next day, EDGE sent back its form saying it needed 90 days, and it left blank where and when I could see anything. It also told me my request had “triggered the aggregation provisions of the policy” – a rule that lets EDGE lump several of one person’s requests together. When I asked to look at the records in two smaller batches as they became ready, EDGE answered: “The response has not changed.“

They thought they could scare me off – but little did they know…

So that same day, October 30th, I filed an inquiry with the Office of Open Records Counsel.

On November 5th, Toni Chadwick, the Open Records Counsel, wrote back. Not all of it went my way. She said 90 days without a reason is “generally” consistent with the law, and that she knew of nothing that requires EDGE to let me look in batches. Fair enough.

The same day, EDGE told me there would be no charge for copies I didn’t want, and no charge for a meeting to look at the records in its office. But it said I was “incorrect about the charge for assembling the materials.”

They said that they would send me a budget, and “Once you provide the direction for which items you still require and pay the estimated fees, we will commence the research.” It added that “each request and email slows down the time it takes to respond.”

They meant that my getting the Office of Open Records Counsel involved would slow my request.

So I asked the Office of Open Records Counsel the question that mattered most – can EDGE make me pay to gather records I only want to look at?

On November 6th, they answered: “For an in-person inspection of records, there can be no charge.”

I sent that to EDGE, along with the line from its own policy, and asked what law or policy lets it charge to gather records I only asked to inspect.

They responded on November 13th, and they sent the new budget – $11,040 across three items.

That’s $4,200 for its communications with the xAI companies, $2,640 for the Chamber, and $4,200 for its own staff and board.

Keep in mind – this is a request for communications – meaning emails. Ones that can be searched electronically.

Each estimate “would need to be paid to EDGE in advance before any search efforts will be undertaken,” and EDGE would give it “up to 4 hours of staff time per week.” The hours EDGE listed add up to at least 88. At four hours a week, that’s more than five months of searching.

That’s almost four times the $3,000 it first asked for. And the two-page letter didn’t mention inspection or answer my question about what law lets EDGE charge for it.

Cause you best believe – if you are charging me 11k – I’m not coming to your office to look at these; I want them hand-delivered. Either way – apparently – they REALLY DO NOT WANT ME TO SEE THESE RECORDS.

So, on November 14th, I sent the budget to Toni Chadwick and asked whether her office would contact EDGE. On the 17th, she told me she’d spoken with Dr. Joann Massey, EDGE’s president and CEO, and was setting up a call with her and EDGE’s general counsel. That call happened this morning.

Then they emailed me the results:

Hi Dr. Massey,

Thank you for taking the time to speak with me this morning. I don’t have an email address for Mark, but please pass along my thanks to him as well.

…

Just to recap, our office’s position is that no charge may be assessed for access to records when an individual is conducting an in-person inspection. Tenn. Code Ann. § 10-7-503(a)(7)(A). I was also able to locate an Attorney General opinion on this topic, Tenn. Op. Atty. Gen. No. 01-201 (February 8, 2001).

Happy to discuss further if either of you would like or answer any follow-up questions!

…

That opinion is worth a read. The Attorney General was asked whether a local government can charge a fee for letting someone look at public records. The answer was “No.” It said the office was “not aware of any provision” in the law “that would allow a local agency to charge a research and/or location fee per se.”

And it said that making someone pay a fee the law doesn’t allow before they can look “would be tantamount to denying the right of inspection.” In other words, charging you before you can look is the same as telling you no.

Now – while this went in my favor – the Open Records Counsel just gives advice. It can’t order EDGE to do anything, and neither can an Attorney General opinion. EDGE could still argue that its budget is for staff time to find and review the records, not for the looking. Under Tennessee law, only a court can order an agency to open its records.

But the state’s position is now in writing, sent to EDGE’s president, and it says the same thing EDGE’s own policy says.

Now, look at what it’s taken to get here. A $3,000 estimate that was never broken down. A missed deadline. Ninety days. A no on batches. “The response has not changed.” Being told I was “incorrect.” Being told my emails slow things down. And then $11,040, paid up front, for records I only asked to look at – a week after the state had already told me there can be no charge.

I can’t tell you why EDGE has fought this hard. But every step has made it harder to see what EDGE and xAI said to each other.

From where I sit, EDGE really doesn’t want me to see these records.

So I’m taking this as a win. But I doubt it’s the end of the story.

Those emails are part of the answer to how xAI ended up in Memphis. Now it’s up to EDGE whether it follows the state’s advice – and its own policy.

UPDATE: I just followed up with the Open Records office about what next steps are if EDGE continues to not follow the law – is my only recourse to sue them. They responded:

“Essentially, yes. The next step would be to file suit pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 10-7-505 for enforcement of the TPRA.”

Does anyone know a lawyer who would help me pro bono?

Sources

  1. My first EDGE request, for the Pidgeon lease records and EDGE’s emails with xAI and the Chamber, October 8th, 2026
  2. EDGE’s answer asking for an estimated payment of $3,000 before producing anything, October 9th, 2026
  3. The lease EDGE produced – the Port Commission and EDGE lease to CTC Property, effective March 1st, 2025
  4. EDGE’s Amended and Restated Public Records Policy (2023), section V.A
  5. Tennessee Code 10-7-503, the Public Records Act
  6. My request to inspect EDGE’s xAI communications in person, October 16th, 2026
  7. My October 29th follow-up and EDGE’s form giving 90 days, October 30th, 2026
  8. My ask to inspect in two batches, and EDGE’s “The response has not changed,” October 30th, 2026
  9. The Office of Open Records Counsel’s answers to my inquiry, November 5th and 6th, 2026
  10. EDGE’s email saying I was “incorrect about the charge for assembling the materials,” November 5th, 2026, and my answer of November 6th
  11. EDGE’s $11,040 budget, November 13th, 2026
  12. My email sending the budget to Open Records Counsel, and her November 17th answer
  13. Open Records Counsel Toni Chadwick’s email to EDGE’s Dr. Joann Massey, November 18th, 2026
  14. Tennessee Attorney General Opinion No. 01-021, “Providing Access to Public Records,” February 8th, 2001
  15. Open Records Counsel’s answers to my follow-up questions, November 18th, 2026
  16. Tennessee Code 10-7-505, going to court to enforce the Public Records Act
  17. My essay, xAI is staying. What should Memphis fight for?